El Pueblo es El mar
Stay tuned!
The documentary will be released soon.

Making the Film

Overview

The project takes place in San Antonio Oeste, San Antonio Este and Las Grutas, in the Argentinian province of Río Negro along the Atlantic coast of northern Patagonia. San Antonio Oeste is the head of the department of San Antonio. Found in the northwest corner of the San Matías Gulf, San Antonio Bay is essential for the local economy and is a key habitat for biodiversity, including acting as a resting and feeding ground for many species of migratory birds.

The Marine Protected Area

The San Antonio Bay Natural Protected Area was created in 1993 by provincial law number 2260. In that same year, it became recognized as an International Site by the Council of the Hemispheric Shorebird Reserve Network. But, it was not until 2014 when the final approval of the San Antonio Bay Natural Protected Area management plan was established. It is expected that in 2022 the management plan for the protected natural area, which should have been revised every 5 years since its creation, will be reviewed and updated.

Three major industries are developed in and around the area: tourism, fishing and the port. The MPA in question is experiencing several environmental problems, such as heavy metal contamination from the former mining plant, open-pit and untreated landfills, the fishmeal factory, unregulated fishing, industrial production of sodium carbonate on the shores of the bay, as well as mass tourism promoted by the claim of being the "most beautiful beach" in Argentina. In addition, the option of installing a gas pipeline from Vaca Muerta to the port of San Antonio Este is being evaluated. This activity is currently prohibited by Provincial Law No. 3308.

The Project

El Pueblo es El Mar tells the story of different coastal communities and stakeholders in an area where marine resources and ecosystems are at the centre of nearly all livelihoods. The project explores the communities’ perspectives that until now have been overlooked and raises awareness about the ecological, social and economic value of the San Antonio Bay Marine Protected Area (ANPBS according to its name in Spanish). This project will highlight the lived experiences, limited management and clashes that occur between conflicts of interest in this protected area. All of these factors serve as learning lessons for the creation and management of Marine Protected Areas (MPAs), not only in Patagonia but in other parts of the world with similar characteristics.

The main objective of the project El Pueblo es El Mar is an educational documentary created thanks to the help and collaboration of the people from San Antonio Bay. This project also includes environmental awareness activities for children and adults, as well as roundtables to promote respect and knowledge of the MPA, which will result in improved conservation and management of the area motivated by the local people.

Study Site

Click  here for more information about the map

The San Antonio Bay Natural Protected Area was created in 1993 by provincial law number 2260. In that same year, it became recognized as an International Site by the Council of the Hemispheric Shorebird Reserve Network. In 1996, with collaboration from the authorities, some activities began in the area, such as the first workshops to develop the management plan, the installation of signage in its territory, and training for teachers, people and companies who were interested in nature tourism, which helped to create a pilot plan for tourism and shorebirds. It was in 1999 when the first specific management measures for San Antonio Bay were issued. But, it was not until 2014 when the final approval of the San Antonio Bay Natural Protected Area management plan was established. During those years, some of the most notable achievements were: the prohibition of the introduction of Crassostrea gigas (1998), the Municipal Land and Environmental Management Plan (2005) and the creation and ranking of the environmental guards (2005). Also in 2005, the Local Conservation Authority of the San Antonio Bay Natural Protected Area (ALC BSA) was created, which now needs to be reactivated with regular meetings and representation of all key stakeholders. This led to further management in 2008, when the boundaries of the Natural Protected Area were expanded from 15,000 to 65,000 ha. Later, in 2011, Provincial Law 4644 on the Conservation of Protected Areas and Wetlands was approved, and the Red Knot was designated as a Municipal Symbol Bird (2013). It is expected that in 2022 the management plan for the protected natural area, which should have been revised every 5 years since its creation, will be reviewed and updated.
Trucks
Trucks drive through sensitive areas, contributing to the degradation of the shell beds and the ecosystem in general
Disturbance of the fauna in the area
4x4
Activity not permitted in the ANPBSA and is popular in summer
Risk: elimination or modification of coastal dunes, landscape alteration, noise pollution and disturbance of feeding and resting places of local fauna
Shorebirds
24 species of shorebirds
e.g., red knots, white-rumped sandpipers, white sandpipers and sea cuckoos
Fishmeal Factory
Produces liquid waste (from the transformation process), solid waste and emissions of odours, gases and particles (founded in 1994)
Risks: water, air and visual pollution
Campers
The circulation of campers modify archaeological material (erosion)
Deterioration of vegetation cover accelerates erosion processes
Human activities, dogs and drones disturb coastal marine fauna
Industrial Fishing
Equipped with bottom trawl
> 90% of landings in San Matías Gulf
Target species: common hake, silver warehou and shrimp
Risk: invasive species, habitat deterioration, loss of biodiversity and tension with artisanal fishers
In the port of San Antonio Este there are nine industrial vessels (Feb 2022)
ALPAT
Sodium carbonate producer (founded in 2005)
Environmental risks: dust, saline effluents, visual impact and noise pollution
Gonzalito Mine, Smelter Plant
To process lead and zinc, mined 100 km away (founded in 1961)
Active for approx. 20 years
Total extraction: 61808 tn of lead and 12725 tn of zinc
Clandestine Dumps
35 clandestine open-air dumps
Risk: contamination from leachate and fish waste (metabisulfite) and greenhouse gases
Octopus Fishing
The octopus (Octopus tehuelchus) fishery is the oldest in the Gulf of San Matías
Low-income activity
Tourism has displaced the octopus fishers by about 80 km
Fishing gear: 30-40 cm iron hooks
Sea Lions
Otaria flavescens and other species on Islote Lobos
Threats: fishing gear, pollution, prey reduction, tourism, habitat degradation and predation
Invasive Species
For example: Undaria pinnatifida
Exponential and unmonitored growth
Impacts on: ecosystems, economy and society
Shell Bed Assemblage
Pleistocene spike of sandy gravel with mollusk remains surrounded by crystalline waters
Ecological importance: habitat for marine mammals, birds and cartilaginous animals
Threats: tourism and camping (human waste)
Artisanal Fishing
Three groups of fishers: shellfishers, longliners and octopus fishers
Target species: mussel, hake, purple clam, scallop and Patagonian octopus
Use of diving with hoses connected to air compressor (for shellfish)
There are 87 artisanal vessels operating in the San Matías Gulf, of which 13 are engaged in diving extraction (Feb 2022)
Legal Landfills
The municipal landfill is open-air and saturated
There is no perimeter fencing or minimum security measures
Risks: dispersion of plastics and disease-transmitting vectors, leaching, greenhouse gases, visual impact and concentration of animals
Tourism
Winter: 40000 (local)
Summer: approx. 300000 (tourists)
The area is overcrowded
Risks: Environmental deterioration, friction with the local population, economic dependence, urban development is not environmentally sustainable
Water Treatment Plan
Treatment capacity: 3500 m3/day
Summer: 6500 m3/day with maximums of 10000 and 15000 m3/day
50% of the population is not connected to sewage services
Bajo Riñon (ALPAT)
Calcium and sodium chloride deposit (600-700 t/day)
Located 4 km from the bay
Lack of sealing waste
Risks: seep into aquifer and visual contamination
Mine Deposit Area
When the company went bankrupt, it abandoned the open-pit heavy metal deposits
Piles containing cadmium, lead, zinc and copper
Between 2017-2018 remediation processes but not all was removed, causing diseases and pollution
Piles containing cadmium, lead, zinc and copper
Threats: lead is a toxic substance, with particularly harmful effects on kids and the environment
The sea, once it casts its spell,
holds one in its net of wonder forever
-- Jacques Cousteu

Meet the Locals

"I love my land. I don’t know what is happening, what is going on, what destroyed this place"

Natividad Pailemán
Octopus fisher (retired)

"There is no protection, here there is none"

Atilio Pailemán
Octopus fisher (retired)

"We are realizing that if we kill the juvenile this coming winter, we won’t be able to survive (we won’t have any livelihood)"

Marcelo Vaccaro
Compressor diver

"One of the main objectives I’ve had since I started to work in the province is to strengthen the environmental institution”

Oscar Echeverría
Chairman of the San Antonio Bay Environmental Protection Agency

"I do my job with a lot of passion, a lot of love. I chose it since I was born"

Tata Aguayo
Compressor diver

"In Rio Negro, the development of sustainable tourism is a constitutional concept. [...] What isn’t planned by ourselves will be planned for us by someone else"

Mariela Messina
Subsecretary of Tourism Developement

"Any activity related to diving is what I like to do, what I know how to do well"

Marcos Brochado
Professional diver

"The area has an enormous diversity of habitats […] that have a plethora of enjoyable ecological attributes"

Maite Navarte
Lecturer at the Universidad of Comahue

"[San Antonio’s identity is] the fishery"

Adelina Cerro
Chef

"The first day I went sailing was by accident […] and even today, I can still remember that moment and the way the ocean was, […] it was love at first sight"

Agustín Sánchez
Captain (Wildlife guide)

"As a social communicator (my role) is to deliver a message every day, to take care of the environment, of the coast, in this absolutely beautiful place we’ve got in the Patagonia [...]"

Ruben Pino
TV-Host

"The sea is everything to me, I don’t know what would be of me if I were missing the sea"

Juan Carlos Pacheco "El tigre del golfo"
Captain (Industrial ship)

"The birds which are environmental indicators speak to me, they tell me what is happening, [...] day by day I see how they are becoming extinct right before my eyes [...]"

Patricia M. González
Biologist, Inalafquen NGO

"When you write on a sheet of paper something that you feel in your heart, people understand it [...], it is contagious, they share it"

Claudio Parra
Patagonian singer & songwriter

"I believe that together we must take care of our bay and our factory is anchored in a very specific place"

Nestor Fabián Muñoz
General Secretary of SPIQyP in Patagonia

"Garbage hurts the sea, it hurts the fish, and after the fish it hurts us"

Tiziano Palacio
Primary school student

"I was born in the sea, [...] the sea and I are one, [...] I am from the sea"

Eloisa "Chichita" Salas
Chef & Entrepreneur

The sea is [...] our life, our resource, our universe. We are the sea

-- Eloisa "Chichita" Salas

Individually, we are one drop.
Together, we are an ocean.
-- Ryunosuke Satoro

Meet the Experts

Belén García Ovide
NGO Activist
Ocean Missions
Iceland
Barbara Horta e Costa
Post-Doc Researcher
CCMAR, Algarve University
Portugal
Patrik Krstinic
Programme Officer
WWF Adria
Croatia
Somrudee Meprasert Jitpraphai
Assistant Professor
Chulalongkorn University
Thailand
Nicole Crane
Senior Scientist
One People One Reef
Western Pacific-Micronesian Islands
Yimnang Golbuu
CEO
Palau International Coral Reef Centre
Palau
Moustapha Ciss
Programme Assistant
SGP Sénégal
Senegal
Francesca Trotman
Founder and Director
Love the Oceans
Mozambique
Jimmy Andino
Executive Director
Centro de Estudios Marinos
Honduras
Rafe Boulon
Retired Chief
Divison of Resource Management & Science of Old Virgin Islands National Park
US Virgin Islands
Jula Selmani
Head of Project Unit
National Agency of Protected Areas
Albania
Andrés Milessi
Coordinator
Oceanosanos
Uruguay
Tommy Melo
Co-Founder and President
Biosfera Cabo Verde
Cape Verde
Jacqueline Gautier-Bernardi
Director
Association Monégasque pour la Protection de la Nature
Monaco
Sonigitu Asibong Ekpe
Scientific Director
Ministry of Environment
Nigeria
Weldon Wade
Communications Coordinator
Bermuda Ocean Prosperity Programme
Bermuda
Daniel Pauly
Principal Investigator, Sea Around Us
University of British Columbia
Canada
Sofiya Shukova
Wildlife Artivist and Conservationist
Advisor at Creature Conserve
Singapore
Colin Wen
Associate Professor
Tunghai University
Taiwan

Marine protection means insurance for healthy oceans, […] for my family, my children, and the future generations

-- Weldon Wade

Events

Drawing competition for kids (Deadline: 24th January 2022)(4 - 11 years old)

We are looking for inspiring poetry and short stories about the ocean and the bay of San Antonio. Any topics and formats are welcome (Winners will receive a prize!)

See winners
Photo competition for youth (Deadline: 24th January 2022) (12-23 years old)

With this competition we invite the children of San Antonio Bay to share their drawings related to the ocean or simply how they enjoyed their summer in San Antonio or Las Grutas (Winners will receive a prize!)

See winners
Poetry competition for adults (Deadline: 24th January 2022)(24 and above)

With this competition we invite the youth of San Antonio Bay to share their best photos that represent what the bay of San Antonio and ocean mean to them. Anything is welcome including animals, people, landscapes or artistic photos. (Winners will receive a prize!)

See winners

Contact us

For questions and suggestions about the events, please contact: puebloeselmar@gmail.com

If you want to know more about the project, write to us at: v.relano@oceans.ubc.ca

If you have questions about donations or require IT-support please reach us at: contact@watersciencepolicy.com

Follow us

Twitter Feed

More Resources

Behind the Scenes

El Pueblo es El Mar’s film production took place between January and February 2022 in San Antonio Bay in Argentinian Patagonia

Meet the Team

Verónica Relaño
Director
PhD Researcher
University of British Columbia
Guillermo Soria
Producer
CS Cinematográfica, Cambarieri Soria
Salvador Luís Cambarieri
Videographer
CS Cinematográfica, Cambarieri Soria
Julia De la Puente
Head of Design
Student
Emily Carr University of Art + Design
Christian Fischer
Knowledge Manager
CEO & Executive Editor
Water Science Policy
Rosana Beatriz Alonso
Research Assistant
Independent Consultant
Biologist and Independent Investigator
Eliana Harrigan
International Coordinator
Co-lead of Partnerships & Editor
Water Science Policy
Agustín Patocchi
Assistant
Student
Superior School of Marine Sciences, University of Comahue
Ezequiel Fiotto
Assistant
Student
Superior School of Marine Sciences, University of Comahue
Juan Lundahl
Social Media Manager
Water Science Policy
Neo Hsueh Yen
IT-Support
Web Developer
Water Science Policy

The making of

Partners